Showing posts with label public plan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label public plan. Show all posts

Thursday, March 18, 2010

Cheap Blogging Crutch 03.18

Green-Bashing Exposes the Rot at the Core of Modern Conservatism
Peter Daou looks at how recent studies showing the rise in US skepticism on global warming coincide with more and more scientific studies showing the existence of global warming and climate change, and contrasts it with right wing and corporate messaging that attempts to discredit science with that of left wing and scientific messaging that. It isn't pretty. Sure the might be a global scientific consensus that id fortified with data that only increases their case year by year, but on the other hand: Al Gore is fat and that is funny. So you can see why science and knowledge has trouble combating a campaign that lets regular people feel like they know better than egghead scientists.

Who’s Buried in the History Books?
A NY Times op-ed on how a conservative campaign to get Grant knocked off the $50 and replaced by Reagan is based in a general disrespect of history, the elevation of misinformation, and the cheapened intellectualism of the US. Wait, knowledge, history, and intelligence sacrificed in the name of political myth-making and political gamesmanship? In America? Sounds like someone is talking crazy.

Post Mortem: Who Killed The Public Option?
With health care about to pass and recent attempts to get the public option passed through reconciliation apparently dead (Shocking! But all those Senators said they were for it, I can't believe that it didn't happen), Talking Points Memo goes through the exact history of how a popular and sensible program that improved the health care system for Americans got removed by our elected betters. I think it had something to do with the fact that it was popular, sensible, and improved the health care system for Americans. Read it. You know, just in case you had a wound you wanted to rub salt in. Which, incidentally, isn't going to be covered in any new health plans.

The HBO Auteur
The NY Times does a profile on giant brain man and TV Jesus, David Simon, while he worked on the about to premiere show Treme, about life in New Orleans post-Katrina. As if a massive article on the conception process of the man who created the best show ever, the Wire, isn't enough to get you excited for Treme, Dominic West, McNutty himself, went out and said that it'd be better than the Wire. Can I just cook this show up and shoot it into my veins already? I need something that distills America into a bleak portrait of poverty, crime, and good people being beaten down by the system.

TOP TEN TURNS 60: The List Known ’Round the World
It is the 60th Anniversary of the FBI's 10 Most Wanted list, so in celebration I think we need to get together, find some tommy guns, give each other colorful nicknames, and go on a multi-state bank robbing spree that results in our violent death at the hands of the feds. Deal? The FBI has decided to celebrate the occasion by putting up a historical article and linking to the mugshots and wanted posters of everyone who has ever been on the list. YMMV. I like my way better.

Tuesday, December 15, 2009

Who could have foreseen?

And it's over. Just as quickly as Joe Lieberman said he'd block a bill with a Medicare buy in, it came out just as quickly. No public option, no buy-in, and nothing to replace it. Liberal Seantors walking around glum faced talking about how "things could have been worse". Yeah, I guess Joe could have released a biological agent in the caucus meetings. That would have been worse. In the end Democrats completely roll themselves, furiously piss off their base, capitulate to a man who is going to o this again and again out of spite, and made a health care bill measurable worse in a way that will bankrupt people and get them killed. Who could have foreseen that this would ever happen?
Joe Lieberman has forced his will on the Senate Democratic caucus and the nation as a whole. After the party reached a compromise last week to effectively drop the public option in exchange for allowing 55- to 64-year-olds to buy into Medicare, that compromise is now in doubt.

Lieberman, an independent from Connecticut, told Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) on Sunday that he will block any bill that includes the buy-in. As the 60th vote needed to overcome a Republican filibuster, he can do that.

Following a caucus-wide meeting Monday evening, the measure was all but scuttled.
So why did they finally cave now? We can blame Rahm Emanuel if we want, but that misses the point. He was just carrying out the wishes of a White House that thinks any bill is a good bill and that they have to pas it nowonwnow so they can turn the focus to fucking up a jobs bill in 2010. The greater source of blame falls to the institution of the Senate, which, as presently constructed, is almost useless in terms of addressing large problems. Or small problems. But they do a good collegial, old boys network, circle jerk like no one else.

And so we finally move to the voting... unless Lieberman wants more cut out and is willing to leverage his sociopathic indifference to humans against 59 other Senators again. Unless some other Senator sees this as an opportunity to strong-arm their way into attempting to get whatever they want in the bill. That'll only probably happen. So congratulations, we all have to buy insurance now and the only things that were going to provide competition to the groups that everyone seems to agree are the problem are gone. I'm sure that and wishing will lower prices. Remember to get out a vote for Democrats in 2010!

Monday, December 14, 2009

Actually, yeah, the health care bill could get worse

Hey, remember that whole point in time last week when everyone was pretty sure that the last painful compromise had been made in the health care fight? When the public option was dropped for a Medicare buy-in and some people were holding out hope that, depending on how things were structured, this might turn out to be better than a weak public option? Yeah... then Joe Lieberman started speaking.
"We've got to stop adding to the bill," said Lieberman. "We have to start subtracting some controversial things."
...
"You have to take out the Medicare buy-in," said Lieberman. "You have to forget about the public option. You probably have to take out the CLASS Act..... If you did that, you'd have an enormous accomplishment. Thirty million Americans who can't afford insurance today would get it. Insurance companies would be more aggressively regulated and costs would be bent down. It's time to get reasonable."
Great news, right? Joe Lieberman wants more compromise, for no discernible reason, and will continue to lie about his motivations for doing so, and the financial and human costs of what his changes will do. So, to the surprise of no one, Lieberman vowed today to filibuster any bill with a Medicare buy-in... despite supporting it when it was part of a little something called the Lieberman/Gore Health Care Plan.

So not only is the Senate health care bill going to get worse, much much worse, it's going to get worse to the point where it's not even a sure thing that it could pass in the House or even keep on some of the Senator who are actually concerned with people's lives; killing reform. Which seems to be Lieberman's actual goal. At what point does catering to his random whims make the bill worse than what going through reconciliation would fashion the bill into? I'd like to find out. Plus, we all found out that the prayers we made to have Joe hit by a flaming sky rock or fall into a wheat thresher... were made to the wrong God. Oh, the indignity.

You know I hate to say it, but I'm beginning to regret electing Joe Lieberman King of the United States and Emperor of Health Care.

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

The last honest man

If you didn't already really, really hate Joe Lieberman with the fire of a thousand suns, our great newspapers have taken it upon themselves this week to try and take that loathing and crank it up into the two or three thousand sun range.

First there was the Wall Street Journal's epic paen to Joe, in which thousands of words are spent memorializing and lauding self-aggrandizing narcissism, hypocritical self-interest, inflated egotism, spite vendettas, and self commissioned statue building. The story really should become the dictionary definition for fellatio, or at least "media fellatio."

The Washington Post took a different angle, showing why everyone hates Joe Lieberman and attempting a pushback on the large bullshit parade he attempt to lead any time he opens his mouth. It's a nice catalogue of grievances, but at the end of the story, while discussing his disdain for the public option, it drops this little nugget:
“He keeps saying over and over that we can’t afford the public option, but the question is whether we can afford the subsidies,” said John Holahan of the Urban Institute.

Confronted with the cost-saving assessments of a strong public option, Lieberman concedes the point, but he says an aggressive government-run plan would put undue pressures on medical providers and force them to shift costs to private insurers. Put simply, he opposes the public option in any form, regardless of whether it reduces costs.
That's right, his "principled" opposition to the public option fully concedes that it would save money. If he knows that, he knows the stronger a public option is, the more money that it saves. Yet still he opposes one. Yet God is still refusing to hit him with a flaming rock from the sky.

So there, just mull that one over as you get to read over and over that the public option was just removed from the Senate health reform bill. Swish that one around the 'ole palate. Push the rage deep down inside and save it for another day, so when you see the inevitable news story praising him for his "contributions" and "action" during the health care debate you can explode out with an emphatic "THATFUCKINGSONOFABITCH", perhaps directed at a loved one or small child. As you think over how hard this man worked to take money out of your pocket and degrade your health care options, one thought will rattle around in your head: "Thanks Connecticut. Thanks for electing him." They're welcome.

The final compromise

Well, to the surprise of no one, Democrats huddled together, thought things through, and came to the conclusion that once again weakness should rules the day and 4 Senators should be allowed to strongarm 56. Yes, the public option is finally out. Oh, they'll claim it wasn't abandoned and that it's still in there, somewhere, and you just have to squint, tilt your head, unfocus your eyes, and believe, then you'll see it. So what's in the deal?
As has been widely reported, one of the trade-offs will be to extend a version of the Federal Employees Health Benefits Plan to consumers in the exchanges. Insurance companies will have the option of creating nationally-based non-profit insurance plans that would offered on the exchanges in every state. However, according to the aide, if insurance companies don't step up to the plate to offer such plans, that will trigger a national public option.

Beyond that, the group agreed--contingent upon CBO analysis--to a Medicare buy in.

That buy-in option would initially be made available to some uninsured people aged 55-64 in 2011, three years before the exchanges open. For the period between 2011 and 2014, when the exchanges do open, the Medicare option will not be subsidized--people will have to pay in without federal premium assistance--and so will likely be quite expensive, the aide noted. However, after the exchanges launch, the Medicare option would be offered in the exchanges, where people could pay into it with their subsidies.
There's more, but that's largely the meat of it. A public option trigger. A mish-mash of national non-profit plans administered by private insurance. Some form of Medicare for the 55-64 set.

Problems? Well, the Medicare buy-in, is pretty much for Medicare in name only and not the real thing. They were unable to expand Medicaid. The public option is in there so people can point at it and say "Look!", but it will be in a form that will not only not be useful if it was enacted, but could never really be triggered. Finally, the "national non-profits" will be run by national for-profits who are the big, giant problem that this health reform was supposed to fix in the first place.

S0, mediocrity wins the day. The grand plan to move our health care system from a 3 out of 10 to a 4 out of 10 is scrapped to just try to make it a 3.1 or, more likely, a 3.09. As more details come out, actual specifics are leaked, and the CBO gives them their "this saves a dollar" cover, we'll likely find out how bad this actually is and all the loopholes that exist. But, for now, it looks as if this is pretty much on the same level of reform as the bill was with a utterly neutered public option that was previously in the bill. Once again, things seemed to have been negotiated on the basis of "looking like you're doing something" as everyone pretends that making a bill worse, arcane, and more confusing to placate 4 people who can't string together a coherent thought or honest statement on health care is a grand achievement. Twas ever thus. So get happy, the last big disappointment and compromise is finally over. *sniff* I'm going to miss getting mad over this stuff.

Monday, December 7, 2009

What else didn't he mention?

Over the weekend the President made yet another trip up to the Senate to meet with the Democratic caucus, remind them yet again of the importance of health care reform, and to remind them yet again of the hellfire and wrath that will be visited upon them by the voters if they show themselves to be completely incompetent instead on only mostly incompetent. Is the 17th time the charm? Well, when the meeting was over, the Senators emerged, their faces filled with smiles, and recommitted themselves....to petty political gamesmanship based on and around what the President did and didn't say.
As President Obama finished his speech to the Democratic caucus in the Capitol's Mansfield Room on Sunday afternoon, Joe Lieberman made his way over to Harry Reid.

The independent who still caucuses with Democrats wanted to point something out to the Majority Leader: Obama didn't mention the public option.

Lieberman was beaming as he left the room and happy to re-point it out when HuffPost asked him what Obama had said about the public health insurance option, perhaps the most contentious issue still facing Democrats as they negotiate their way toward a final health care reform bill.
Ahh Barry, you can't even throw a pretend bone of support in a private meeting to an idea you championed during the campaign. But I'm sure when the public option is stripped out and replaced with some bad compromise (newest plan: make the public option private run), you'll talk about how you wished it could have been in, but it just slipped your mind to ever fight for it once over a nearly one year period. Also not mentioned: abortion. So I'm sure that bodes well for Ben Nelson's "Silly women, don't you know that old men from Nebraska have more sense about your lady bits than you do?" bill. On the bright side, Joe Lieberman was thrilled by everything that went on in the meeting. So, I'm sure the American people at large are going to be fucked hard, because I can't recall him ever being ecstatic about anything that made my life better.

So now everyone gets to be paranoid and angry over what is and isn't mentioned in 'rally' speeches to cretins. But soon these important battles over omissions and inclusions will be over, and in the next few months and over the next seven times the President heads up to Capitol to rally everyone, the Senate can start arguing on more important things: like his syllable emphasis and voice inflection. Maybe after that, there will be an actual debate on the actual worthiness of some of the proposals being considered.

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

One more compromise

Good news for those of you who thought that the battle over the public option was going to result in a version that was too strong and too helpful to millions of Americans. It seems we aren't going to have that problem. First, there was a bit of analysis that said the public option as presently constructed by the Senate won't actually cut costs all that much, then there was the new revelation that they were scrapping what they had in exchange for something even weaker that would lure both Maine Republican Senators. What exactly is that plan? I'd like to tell you Flounder, but the new plan is on double secret probation.
Sen. Tom Carper (D-Del.), who has been tapped by Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) to come up with a Plan B approach to the public option controversy that has divided Democrats, has been working closely with liberal and conservative Democrats, as well as Sen. Olympia Snowe (R-Maine).
...
Carper, a junior member of the Finance Committee, was tight-lipped on the details of his plan, but noted that he has been talking extensively with Snowe. He pointed out that he served with Snowe, and her husband, former Maine Gov. John McKernan (R), in the House.

Snowe favors a trigger proposal, where a public option would go into effect if the private health insurance market falters. The trigger has been soundly rejected by some liberals in Congress.
Whew! I was worried there for a second that a public option might get passed. Now we get the best of both worlds: those who get support a public option get to claim they passed one and those who oppose it get to be secure in the notion that one will never come about because the trigger to enact one will never be reached. Of course, that is, if the super duper new plan is even as "good" as a triggered public option. Hell, the compromise might just be to write "the public option" on a post-it note, put in under a glass case and allow us to view it from afar. It'll do about as much good as current designs of the public option will do.

So there you are: one more compromise that degrades your faith in government and the ability to pass meaningful reform. Actually, I should amend that; it's one more compromise...before a bunch of other compromises. Yeah, we don't even know what those will be yet. I bet Democrats are going to be surprised when they find their base isn't as thrilled with our elected betters as much as our elected betters seem to be thrilled with our elected betters. Ah well, at least we were spared the scourge of a mechanism that might slightly reduce health care costs. It's better that way, we just would have used the savings on another war.

Monday, November 2, 2009

Quote of the Day

Joe Lieberman (Scum Fuck-CT), moving beyond merely lying about the public option and health care reform to openly advocating for you to heap your loathing and disdain on him as well as begging you to test out any type of voodoo doll on him.

BOB SCHIEFFER: But is what you're also saying is that nothing is better than a government health insurance or a gov- health insurance reform that includes a public option. Nothing is better than that?

SENATOR JOE LIEBERMAN: Well, the truth is that nothing is better than that because I- I think we ought to follow, if I may, the- the doctors' oath here. In Congress says we deal with health care reform, do no harm.

I don't know Joe, I think maybe to the 45,000 people each year who die because of a lack of health care, nothing isn't really a great option, though they do appreciate how relevant you now feel. To the countless thousands who are bankrupted each year because of medical costs, I'm sure that the option of doing nothing isn't that great either, thought they do really sympathize with just how sandy your vagina is after Ned Lamont beat you in the Democratic primary way back when.

But not content to merely play with people's lives because he wasn't getting enough media attention, Joe decided that he wanted to up the ante and blame everyone else for forcing him to join with Republicans to filibuster health reform.
SENATOR JOE LIEBERMAN: Yeah, but I'd say to the people who are all of a sudden making the public option a government health insurance company, the litmus test here, they're stopping us from getting something done.
...
I'd say to them, don't stop us from getting something important and good done for the Americans.
Joe, when around 57-59 Senators are all in agreement about a public option, they aren't the ones holding things back and stopping things from getting done. I know around 60% of the populace would like a public option too, but you've already explained that: we're not as smart as you, the man who doesn't understand anything he's actually saying about health care.

I'll say this for Joe, he may be a contemptible, back stabbing, self important, third rate liar, but he lets you know just how badly he wants to fuck you over and lets you know where he stands. Even if it is the opposite of where he used to stand.

Wednesday, October 28, 2009

Cheap Blogging Crutch 10.28

Fox-Friendly Poll on Imaginary White House Policies
From Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting comes a report of a dandy of a poll from Fox News and Zogby whereupon they ask the question if Americans think that Obama's communist diversity czar's imaginary desire to force out the "good white people" in the broadcast industry to make room for the blacks and the gays and the gay blacks represents a threat to free speech. Nothing like a little conspiratorial race bait push polling to start your day. Gee, I wonder why it is that the Obama Administration doesn't like Fox News?

Analysis: Public Option Is Likely Popular in Most Blue Dog Districts
Nate Silver of 538 works his number witchcraft to look at the popularity of the public option....in every single congressional district. The conclusion? That the public option has support in almost 2/3rds of all districts and in regards to the biggest Democratic gainsayers, the Blue Dog caucus, the public option holds majority support in 34 of 52 of their districts. The conclusion supposedly being that a public option should have more support of our elected betters. Ahh Nate, your cold robot logic has failed you again. Don't you know no one in Congress actually cares about what its constituents thinks? But we do appreciate you giving us yet another mathematically valid reason to hate everyone in Congress.

New York Fed’s Secret Choice to Pay for Swaps Hits Taxpayers
Pop quiz: how do you get AIG to look good? Answer: Make sure they're being compared to Tim Geithner. That's right our beloved Treasury Secretary Timmy demanded that the US government pay AIG 100 cents on the dollar for their utterly worthless credit default swaps when AIG was only seeking to get 40 cents on the dollar for them. This cost taxpayers and additional $13 billion dollars. The kicker? This allowed AIG to pay back the $14 billion it owed to Timbo's former employer Goldman-Sachs. Next time Tim, can you put on some cowboy gear, cover your face with a black bandanna, tell us "to reach for the sky", and make us pile the money into a burlap sack with a dollar sign on it? If we're going to get robbed, can we at least get to appreciate the theatre of it?

Losing Net Neutrality: The Worst Case Scenario
Gizmodo links to a half satirical/half terrifying representation of what kind of internet deal we'll be getting from cable companies if Congress votes to ditch net neutrality. Why wouldn't we want our internet priced out and divided up like cable channels, everyone loves how that works, don't they?

LHC Reawakens, Sending Proton Beams Running at the Speed of Light
Finally the scientific community gets off its lazy, goldbricking asses and starts trying to kill God in earnest again. They've fixed the helium leak, stopped the problem they've had with magnets overheating, scrapped plans to convert the LHC into a pussy magnet, and found that missing pallet of particles that idiot Jenkins misplaced. Hopefully within the next few months God will be dead or the French/Swiss border will find it has a new black hole taking up residence and consuming our solar system. Just get it over with, it's not like any of us have jobs or anything to live for.

Harry has got problems, man

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, gettin' all third person when discussing Joe Lieberman deciding he'll filibuster health care reform
"Joe Lieberman is the least of Harry Reid's problems," Reid told reporters at his weekly press conference.
I'll say. I can think of a few expletive filled ones off the top of my head. Not that I want to pile on Harry Reid and his mistakes after his latest staggering failure. These are, after all, mistakes we all made when we heard him say that a public option was in the Senate bill. I mean when we all heard him announce it a few days back, I made the assumption, like most others, that he had made some hoary, evil blood pact with the pig molesters, avowed pederasts, and spineless insects that populate the Nelson/Lincoln/Landrieu/Bayh/Lieberman end of the caucus to actually do something crazy, like letting a bill with the overwhelming support of Democrats in Congress get voted on. No, that seems like it was a bridge too far.

But that isn't Reid's problem. No, the problem Reid has that's bigger than Lieberman, is his staggering inability to count. Or, at least be able to count to 60. We've all been there one time or another, where our massively important plans were ruined when the lack of basic counting and math skills conspired to derail them. Granted, it was when we were four, but there we are. And it happened to Harry Reid too, when he announced he was moving forward on legislation without checking to see if the waffling cretins in his caucus were on board. Naively thinking that people who were elected as Democrats would actually find Democratic priorities important. But that's the sad end point we've reached with Democratic leadership: we can't even rely on them to have basic counting skills. Abilities that five year olds possess are just out of the reach of our elected betters.

So sorry, we don't get to move on to other things, like climate change, getting angry over the same cast of characters fucking up on that bill. Nope, still stuck on health care, as the Senate decides that the compromise of a compromise of a compromise......probably needs two or three more compromises in there. Maybe four. Get excited!

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Who could have foreseen?

Human swine Joe Lieberman (I-CT)
Lieberman told reporters today that he would in fact filibuster any health care bill he doesn't agree with--and right now, he doesn't agree with the public option proposal making its way through the Senate.

"I told Senator Reid that I'm strongly inclined--i haven't totally decided, but I'm strongly inclined--to vote to proceed to the health care debate, even though I don't support the bill that he's bringing together because it's important that we start the debate on health care reform because I want to vote for health care reform this year. But I also told him that if the bill remains what it is now, I will not be able to support a cloture motion before final passage. Therefore I will try to stop the passage of the bill."
My oh my. Of course he wouldn't want a public option, I mean it's not like he ever argued for making health care cheaper and try to strive for universal coverage, especially when he was running for re-election as an Independent after he lost the Democratic primary.
What I’m saying to the people of Connecticut, I can do more for you and your families to get something done to make health care affordable, to get universal health insurance.
...
MediChoice to allow anybody in our country to buy into a national insurance pool like the health insurance pool that we federal employees and Members of Congress have. ...It will cover 95% of those who are not covered now, and it will reduce the pressure on rising costs for all the millions of others.
Wait, he argued for expanding and creating more single payer government health care plans in 2006 but feels an even more watered down public option is much too generous and expensive for the peasants in 2009? Not to mention that all the reasons he gives for opposing a public option now are utterly without merit. God, I command you to smite this fuck with a flaming sky rock.

Who could have ever foreseen this waffling, spineless fuckup would to try to stop important Democratic priorities that elections were won on, like health care reform, by not even allowing it to be voted on? Oh, Rachel Maddow:



So glad all these Democratic efforts to placate this spoiled, self-centered egomaniac have engendered such stunning and obvious benefits for the American people.

Monday, October 26, 2009

Your afternoon cryptic comment on health care

From TPM, comes this little gem about Majority Leader Harry Reid's 3:15 press conference where he will announce that the public option will make it into the Senate health reform bill with an "opt-out" clause for states...or not. Because we need another cryptic layer of intrigue in the health debate. Maybe he'll announce that he tried hard but can't get it in, or that there will be some sort of public option "trigger", or that he'll be running for re-election as a woman. Who knows?
Democrats are being very tight lipped today about exactly what Reid will say, but are suggesting strongly that there will be news.
Gee, you think? Until such a time as that alleged news happens These Bastards just wants to strongly wish Harriet Reid success in her gender re-assignment surgery and upcoming re-election campaign. Solidarity, sister.

EDIT: Opt out public option. And he'll be running for re-election in a giant furry wolf suit.

Hmm, enacting health reform early...sounds like a crazy idea

How fait accompli is some kind of health reform right now? Well, it's basically to the point where everyone glosses over tiny things like the White House opposing the public option in the Senate and Harry Reid having to lead the way on his own and just moves on to a debate about how soon to implement health reform proposals. Because how can you be expected to get re-elected or reap the popularity of health care reform in 2010 if it doesn't kick in until 2013? There's also something about helping people in need and providing much needed relief in what is actually a life or death situation for blah blah blah blah blah blah blah.
The most significant changes to the health care system wouldn’t kick in until 2013 – two election cycles away. With Republicans expected to make next year a referendum on health care reform, Democrats are quietly lobbying to push up the effective dates on popular programs, so they'll have something to run on in the congressional midterms.

Democrats are anxious to mix the good with the bad since some of the pain would be phased in early, including more than $100 billion in industry fees that critics say could be passed on to consumers.

“We want to be able, within the cost framework and the implementation framework, to have as much start as early as possible, even though we know all of it can’t,” said Sen. Debbie Stabenow (D-Mich.), a Finance Committee member who is working with other senators on the effort. “And the White House wants to have as much as possible to start.”
Among the proposals: make prescription drug discounts available to seniors as well as start randomly adding poisons into those drugs as part of the "death panel" program, tax credits for small businesses, a high risk pool for filth with pre-existing conditions like rape, low birth-weight, or high birth-weight, and money to hire ILM to do enough CG and special effects work to make it look like the severely underwhelming minor tweaks to our system were a massive overhaul and top to bottom reforming of American health care.

Of course there is opposition to these efforts. Sen John Cornyn (R-TX) argues that this is just a seedy and transparent attempt to get people to see the benefit of the legislation by letting them, you know, enroll in programs and get coverage. Plus there's that unfair election advantage where people might be fit to reward Democrats and punish Republicans just because one made an attempt at reform while the other shrieked about grandma getting ganked. And really that's what this all comes down to: elections. Because isn't that the whole point of doing something like this: so one can get re-elected and look good politically? It's certainly not about providing the best and cheapest plan and reforms to cover the American people, so the process of elimination only really leaves politics.

Friday, October 23, 2009

Your morning cryptic quote about health care

After a late afternoon flurry of quotes and stories about how things might be looking up for the public option in the Senate bill, and that Harry Reid had made a decision to include it in the bill, someone from Reid's office stepped forward to offer an update on the status of his mind.
ABC reported today that they have the goods, citing Democratic sources and claiming Reid “has concluded he can pass a bill with a public option.” ABC said Reid is now convinced that even if some moderates are still holding out against it, they will ultimately vote for it on the procedural vote to get it past a filibuster.

Not so much, the senior Senate aide claims. “He has not concluded anything yet,” the aide said of Reid. “But he is more optimistic.”
It's not quite a full "we're leaning towards talking about a public option" on the Reid Zen-meter, but yet another time in which we're supposed to gauge the esoteric status updates of the Majority Leader's mind to decide whether or not we we should be jumping off of bridges over the public option. But such are the arcane measures of the Senate, where Olympia Snowe talks about using a public option 'trigger' as a means of securing her vote and then tells everyone that she won't vote for a bill with any public option when it looks like at the very least a 'trigger' will be in.

But there we are. Daily updates from Reid about the possibilities of maybes, extensive discussions on talking about talking, how you 'like-like' a public option but don't 'like-like' it, and various and sundry texts about conclusions and your state of mind, are considered positive signals to everyone about your leadership and stewardship of the Senate negotiations, such as it is. This just in: Reid is looking into the option of considering calling a quorum to gauge support for whether he has enough votes for the discussion on the question of declaring Opposite Day before any final health care vote. Maybe. I hope all this bullshit leads somewhere productive and nottowards the most obvious conclusion: "Ohhh we tried, for serious, but we'll just have to accept the milquetoast reform you all knew we were going to pass months ago. Honest, we made an attempt. Didn't you see all those quotes about 'maybes' and 'conclusions' and discussing discussions? Too bad, no public option."

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Your morning cryptic quote about health care

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, giving a master class on how not to inspire confidence on health care
A reporter tried to pin Reid down by asking whether negotiations were moving towards, or against, the inclusion of the public plan.

“The negotiations are leaning about a public option,” Reid said.

Asked for clarification by puzzled reporters, Reid added: “We’re leaning towards talking about a public option.”
....Good? I guess that's a positive.....or a negative.....or....what? Leaning towards talking about a public option? A debate over over whether to have a debate?

Sen. Tom Harkin is saying there's 52 solid votes for a public option in the Senate. But because everything is filibustered now that means to add a public option into the bill on the floor, the public option has to have 60 votes for it or against it to get it in or out. Which it doesn't in either case. So in other words: the public option has to be in there before it gets to the floor or else it isn't ever going to get in. So...I guess it's good that they're at least working up the guts to have a talk about possibly considering a debate about the run up to having an opinion about possibly putting a public option in. Maybe.

I guess that's as positive a statement as you can get about Democratic leadership these days: they at least haven't ruled out the best option for actual reform and coverage that vast majorities of the American people, their own party, and their own elected members support. Let's lean towards talking about not hitting them with sticks.

Monday, October 19, 2009

Pollings

Next time a Senator tries to tell the public that there just isn't support for a public option, they can only pass a week kneed version, or that American's don't want one, I hope someone there has the good decency to spit in their eye. The only people who are opposed to the public option are in the Senate.
On the issue that has been a flash point in the national debate, 57 percent of all Americans now favor a public insurance option, while 40 percent are opposed. Support has risen since mid-August, when a bare majority, 52 percent, said they favored it. (In a June Post-ABC poll, support had been at 62 percent.)

If run by the states and available only to those who lack affordable private options, support for a public plan jumps to 76 percent. Under those circumstances, even a majority of Republicans, 56 percent, would be supportive, about double their level of support without such a limitation.
Furthermore 56% favor making it mandatory for all Americans to buy insurance with the number jumping to 71% if government provides subsidies for lower income folks. Of note is the fact that the poll also asked specifically if people would prefer a public option bill with no Republican support or a bipartisan bill with no public option. The public option beat bipartisanship 51% to 37%. Americans prefer a good bill to the Senate wanking itself off. I think I just heard Max Baucus die a little inside.

With news like this, Nancy Pelosi attempting to shame the Senate into a public option bill using CBO numbers as a bludgeon, 52 Democratic Senators thinking that maybe the five holdouts ought to get the fuck onboard, and rumors of competence from Harry Reid, is it too much to get my hopes up? Probably yes, as on the other hand Reid is Reid, Obama lost his balls somewhere during his acceptance speech, and Senate negotiations involve one actual human who is unequivocally for the public option and knows how to breathe through his nostrils. As is always the case with the Senate: lower your expectations. Lower them to the point where Max Baucus coming to burn down your house is a pleasant surprise. It's the only way to keep sane.

Monday, October 12, 2009

It begins

It seems a little late, but I guess even nefarious, money grubbing plans to kill any health care reform were delayed by the interminable bullshit that goes on in the Senate Finance Committee. Yes, the insurance industry is deciding to come out and poison the debate as best it can: by claiming your insurance rates are going to go up, up, up.
After working for months behind the scenes to help shape health care reform, the insurance industry is now sharply attacking the emerging plan with a report that maintains Senate legislation would increase the cost of a typical policy by hundreds, or even thousands, of dollars a year.
...
Late Sunday, the industry trade group America's Health Insurance Plans sent its member companies a new accounting firm study that projects the legislation would add $1,700 a year to the cost of family coverage in 2013, when most of the major provisions in the bill would be in effect.
...
"Several major provisions in the current legislative proposal will cause health care costs to increase far faster and higher than they would under the current system," Karen Ignagni, the top industry lobbyist in Washington, wrote in a memo to insurance company CEOs.

The study projected that in 2019, family premiums could be $4,000 higher and individual premiums could be $1,500 higher.

My God, if a lobbyist said it then it must be true. Just one question though, since I seemed to have misplaced my slide rule and abacus: is this more or less than health care premiums have risen over the past decade and will continue to rise over the next decade? Because it seems about the same. So is that the argument? "Unless we scuttle this health care bill we will see a rise in health care costs almost indistinguishable from what is already going on." Isn't this essentially an argument for why the current bill shouldn't be so beneficial to the health insurance industry, should try to make actual reforms instead of timid incremental garbage, and should, I don't know, provide some sort of public option in order to compete with the insurance costs that the insurance companies are saying are going to keep going up for a bill without a public option? I'm sure our elected betters will get right on top of that.

Speaking of our elected betters: weren't all those concessions you made to the health insurance industry (along with the pharmaceutical industry and every other health care industry) supposed to garner their support? Or were those ads we saw once a few months ago all of it? Or is this just another example of Democrats making concessions in order to get the support of groups that never end up supporting them and actively work against them? I think we know the answer to that. Bang up job once again Democrats!

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

Shep~!

It's time for another episode of Shep Smith: Man of Conscience. The show where Fox News' constant unending shilling for the GOP and corporations finally drives humble broadcaster Shep Smith into a furious rage, whereupon he must find a victim and smash them to death with facts.

The poor bastard on the receiving end this time? Sen. John "I didn't goaltend for any Penguin Cup teams" Barrasso (R-Wyoming). What was Shep pissed about? Lies about the public option and the fact that the insurance companies own our government lock stock. Shep starts getting some of that Taibbi-style righteous fury going. All-in-all it has been a pretty good day for publicly shaming health care liars on the TV. Enjoy.

Cheap Blogging Crutch 10.06

Sotomayor shows she's no Clarence Thomas as Supreme Court opens
New Liberal Hispanic Satan took her seat on the Supreme Court Monday and thanks to some reinforcement of the court's foundations, the ground did not open up and swallow everyone whole. One interesting note: she apparently asked more question in on hour than Justice Clarence Thomas has asked...ever. And that's not an exaggeration. He hasn't spoken in court in years. Way to put that seat to good use Clarence. I don't see why anyone would want to use that seat to ask questions before deciding stuff. Rookie mistake, Sotomayor, rookie mistake.

Shroud Of Turin Reproduced; Italian Group Says Relic Is Man-Made, Fake
If there's one thing I've learned over the years is that religions in general tend to respond really positively when scientists come in with facts, figures, experiments, means testing, and evidence to back up their claims towards aspects of science and the natural world. So I'm sure they'll be extra happy now that science has used its powers to start chipping away at religious dogma and relics.

Burden of Proof on Obama's Origins
Hey, didn't you think it would be a great idea to read a story about the lead nut "investigating" the Obama birth certificate "controversy", Orly Taitz, that treated her as just a normal working mom trying to uncover all the vast insane conspiracies she believes in? No? Well fuck you, because the Washington Post did. Because what this country needs is for more newspapers to spend more time profiling everyone with a crackpot conspiracy about the President.

Obama quietly tries to shore up Senate support for public option
According to the LA Times, President Obama and the White House have been working for the last few weeks now to make sure that a public option is included in any final health care bill. Hey great, better to push for it at the end instead of twisting arms in the beginning, right? No? It would have been better to push hard for this months ago instead of spending all that time undercutting the public plan with statements about how a public plan isn't important? Ah well, at least this will allow them to offer up a meek "we tried" when there's no public option and thus no real mechanism for driving down costs.

No Exit: The never-ending lunacy of Betsy McCaughey.

Did you ever wonder where every crazy conspiracy, shoddy statistic, outright lie, and death panel type rumor in our health care debate came from? Chances are it came from long time health reform advocate Betsy McCaughey. I don't know what's more stunning: that so much bullshit can be generated by one person or that she's still taken somewhat seriously by our mainstream media betters.

Friday, October 2, 2009

Hey wonderful

Finally some good news. Senate Democrats have come out and stated, definitively, that there will be a public option in any final bill that comes out of Congress. Alright boys, way to show some conviction!
Senate Democratic leaders signaled Thursday that their version of health care overhaul will include some form of a public option,
Wonderful to hear. This is apropos of nothing, but I wonder why Politico used a comma to end that sentence up there. That was weird. Hmmm.
, but it may be limited in scope so they can secure 60 votes to break a Republican filibuster.
Ahhh! You rotten sons of bitches. You're doing it again. You're failing again. You see...wait, what? You have something to say Harry Reid?
"We are going to have a public option before this bill goes to the president's desk," Reid said in a conference call with constituents, referring to some kind of government plan.

"I believe the public option is so vitally important to create a level playing field and prevent the insurance companies from taking advantage of us," he said.
Oh good, because earlier it seemed like you were loading up statements like that with tons of caveats and...
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) called the public option a "relative term," and Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) said, "There is not one way to Rome; there are lots of ways to Rome."

"Remember, a public option is a relative term," Reid said. "There's a public option, there's a public option, and there's a public option. And we're going to look at each of them."
Oh Jesus Christ, stop talking! Nothing you say is good, nothing you do is good. I choose to understand these statements the way I would understand statements from a suave Gruber-esque German terrorist who tells me that he will let me and my family go......if I just give him the codes to the mainframe. I know what's he's saying should sound good, but I just can't shake the feeling that the second I listen, we'll all be murdered violently.

So when Reid says "relative term" and starts trying to parse out degrees of public options, that just means something terrible is on the horizon. In fact, that might mean health care isn't even going to happen at all. The only way to rectify this is to throw Harry Reid off the top of Nakatomi Tower before he kills us all. You know I'm right.